おす、みなさん。これで、ぼくのイキオンプロジクトケツパツイコンです。
Vector Icon (Ketupat)
(Home Icon)
(Contact Icon)
Pixel Icon (Ketupat)
(Home Icon)
(Contact Icon)
Critique
Q1. In your opinion,what does the icon tells you? What is the message did you see from the selected icon?
Q1. In your opinion,what does the icon tells you? What is the message did you see from the selected icon?
Q2. In your opinion,does the icons looks or related with the Malay "Ketupat"
Q3, Feedback and suggestion, any weakness or goodness about this icon?
Selection Form
Q1. How was the icon design.
A) Great
B) Average
C) Poor
Q2. Is the color combination good or suite for the "Ketupat" theme?
A) Yes
B) Quite
C) No
Q3. Did the icon bring out a clarify message of "Home" and "Contact" for Pixel Icon?
A) Yes
B) Quite
C) No
Q4. Q3. Did the icon bring out a clarify message of "Home" and "Contact" for Vector Icon?
A) Yes
B) Quite
C) No
BIG ICONS.
ReplyDeleteQ1. In your opinion,what does the icon tells you? What is the message did you see from the selected icon?
Actually, I didn't really see the 1st and 2nd ketupat as labeled.. I thought it was just some random design @@;
Q2. In your opinion,does the icons looks or related with the Malay "Ketupat"
The first one yes, the 2nd one... looks more like chest board.
Q3, Feedback and suggestion, any weakness or goodness about this icon?
Why not just remove the triangle at the bottom of the home icon.. the 2nd one.. maybe you can make it like the 1st one..?
SMALL ICONS
Q1. In your opinion,what does the icon tells you? What is the message did you see from the selected icon?
The home icon does portray the house look. and the contact icon too.
Q2. In your opinion,does the icons looks or related with the Malay "Ketupat"
The 1st one yea, 2nd one is the colour.
Q3, Feedback and suggestion, any weakness or goodness about this icon?
This I'm really not sure what to say..
Q1. How was the icon design.
ReplyDeletefor the vector icon, it looks fine; for the pixel icon, looks old fashion and tradition
B) average
Q2. Is the color combination good or suite for the "Ketupat" theme?
yes
Q3. Did the icon bring out a clarify message of "Home" and "Contact" for Pixel Icon?
yes for vector icon, not quite for the pixel icon-contact icon
all the opinion and critique is shown together with your selective form. im not quite of an art person, just to say...you still can improve more than you think you can do. =)
Q1: B
ReplyDeleteQ2: B
Q3: A
Q4: Home:A Contact:B
1. B
ReplyDelete2. B
3. B
4. B
Pixel
Home
- cant regconize, juz look like icon, but not home, dunno what is it
Contact
- well, hav malay feel. can see clear that it is a contact icon, but for me, i linked to sarong, not ketupat.
Vector
Home
- nice effort
- but weird hse... since up roof, down roof?
Contact
- phone looks...flat? static? sumthing no rite... i think it is very thin...
- wrg lighting on d board??? its under shadow rite? why got lighting at d upper right?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteCritique
ReplyDelete1) erm, i must say the msg is not clear, i was thinking tat it was a normal design.
2)no, coz ketupat, look like a diamond shape. and i think bcoz of the colour la, it is shiny. tat why it dont show the ketupat characteristic
3)*answer in no.1 and no2)
Selection Form
1)b
2)b
3)b
4)b